Wednesday, October 10, 2007
Catalona/Barcelona
Being a huge soccer fan, a Manchester united soccer at that, I have taken to watching many soccer matches in England and abroad. And have come across something I did not know existed, until watching Barcelona play. The internal fighting in Spain between Spanish - Spain and Catalonia. Indeed, Barcelona Football club, which is also referred to as, "The Catalonian Giants," have been representing their people for a long time. A footballer at Barcelona "forced" the President of the Club to put into every player's contract clause that they had to learn Catalonian. The player was an activist, but I did not know how serious he was, until he refused to join the Spanish national team, but instead play for the amateur Catalonia rebel side. But, before he refused to play for the national team, he had initially refused to train at Real Madrid, where the national team traditionally practiced. But besides those incidents I never knew how serious the division was within Spain about the Catalonia issue. Now, the Catalonian's are having a special show at hte Frankfurt Book Fair, and they have barred the Spanish media from entering. The books on display speak about the battle the Catalonian's have faced to save their language, after it was banned twice from Spain in 1714 and 1939. I read this and was shocked and appalled at the Spanish government's attempt to ban the language, in essence an attempt to destroy the culture of the people. In South Africa the same thing was done, but not throughout the country, but in the schools. Forcing children to learn in Afrikaans, resulting in the Soweto uprising, where students demonstrated for their right to learn in their own languages and resulting in some students loosing their lives. It is an unfortunate thing in this world that we do look down upon the smaller languages, and immediately reduce the people who speak them to "nothingness." It is a fault we humans have, and a fault we have to work on.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
3 comments:
Interesting post, it's amazing how many human issues play out on the sporting field. Do you think this is just a case of the majority language beating down the minority language, or is there more at stake here? what would happen if california decided to force everyone to learn spanish, or if arizona made everyone learn navajo... what would the reaction of the rest of the US be? It would be a good idea to flesh out both sides of the argument, and to include references that you are drawing upon in your post!
It's amazing how much tension language can cause. I feel like it is comparable to tensions in religion in the world. Language is a part of a personal identity, and banning a language is like banning a person from being themselves. I can't imagine if someone told me I had to stop speaking English- I would feel so lost. It seems like banning a language can have a lot of negative results, but can you think of any potentially positive outcomes?
I do not personally see any positive outcomes from banning a language, because languages are unique and rich in themselves, that we only stand to lose from banning them. The bilingual root if offered is always the best option, in my humble opinion.
If California forced everyone to learn spanish, and Arizona forced everyone to learn Navajo, it would certainly cause an initial backlash. For many who have been raised and taught English would initially not be too pleased, but, when one takes it into consideration, learning another language can only benefit the country. And the those outside those two states better buckle down and start to learn those languages. But that would only occur if there is huge majority of Spanish speakers or Navajo speakers; then the minority, as I have stated in my other blogs,would have to learn the language of the majority.
Post a Comment